The Myth of Multitasking – Brief
Original Post
I'd like to share a valuable principle with you. It's something I've taught to many business owners and executives I've worked with. This principle may go against the grain of some of your beliefs about time and the best way to get things done. Because of that, I ask you to keep an open mind.
Multitasking is a myth. It just plain doesn't exist.
Does that shock you? Multitasking has become something of a heroic word in our vocabulary. Many executives pride themselves on their ability to "multitask". Recent job descriptions that I have seen even ask that potential employees have the ability to multitask. A current national commercial sings the praises of multitasking. However, multitasking, as most people understand it, is deceptively counter-productive. Multitasking is tremendously costly. Multitasking hurts us every time we attempt to engage in it.
I should clarify a few definitions. When I speak of multitasking as most people understand it, I am not referring to doing something completely mindless and mundane in the background such as exercising while listening to this CD, eating dinner and watching a show, or having the copy machine operate in the background while you answer emails. For clarity's sake, I call this "background tasking".
When most people refer to multitasking they mean simultaneously performing two or more things that require mental effort and attention. Examples would include saying we're spending time with family while were researching stocks online, attempting to listen to a CD and answering email at the same time, or pretending to listen to an employee while we are crunching the numbers. What most people refer to as multitasking, I refer to as "switchtasking." Why?
Because the truth is we really cannot do two things at the same time—we are only one person with only one brain. Neurologically speaking, it has been proven to be impossible. What we are really doing is switching back and forth between two tasks rapidly, typing here, paying attention there, checking our "crackberry" here, answering voicemail there back and forth back and forth at a high rate. Keep this up over a long period of time, and you have deeply engrained habits that cause stress and anxiety and dropped responsibilities and a myriad of productivity & focus problems. It's little wonder so many people complain of increasingly short attention spans!
When we speak of multitasking, what we really mean is that we are switchtasking: switching rapidly between one task and another. Yet, each time we switch, no matter how quickly that switch takes place in our mind, there is a cost associated with it. It's an economic term called switching cost—and the switching cost is high.
When I shared this principle of switchtasking to a CEO of a respected national company, she was astounded. We did a budgeting exercise where we looked at how much time she was spending in a given week. In the process of budgeting her time and looking at how much time she was spending on each activity, we found that she was extremely over budget in what she thought she could accomplish in a week. The truth is, there are only 168 hours in a week, and yet she had put down that she was accomplishing 188 hours worth of work in that week! As we went through the process, we realized where the extra time was coming from. It was from the fact that she was doing research at the same time that she was spending time with her family. When we came across this, I taught her how multitasking was a myth. She was spending time either with one or the other. She was switching rapidly between the two. In reality she was rarely spending any time with her family. She was really doing business research in the presence of her family. There is happy end to this story, however.
The next day we met she burst into the room, full of excitement. She exclaimed, "I'll have you know that I spent time with my family last night and I didn't multitask! I got home and said let's go to dinner. My kids were surprised. But we went to the restaurant and I paid attention to them and I didn't think about anything else but spending time with my family. At first I don't think they took me seriously. After they realized that I was really spending time with them and paying attention to them they were excited and I could tell they really appreciated it."
This CEO had come to understand that not only was switchtasking hurting her business, but it was taking a toll on her family. Once she clearly understood the truth and received some guidance on how to take action, she committed make changes. Her business, her family, and she are all better because of it.
May I offer the following "beginning steps" to help slow down the switchtasking in you life?
1. Take control over technology
Your cell phone ringer (even on vibrate) doesn't need to be on all the time. You can turn off email notification on your computer as well. Become master over the nagging beeps and buzzes by creating some silence.
2. Schedule what you can schedule
Set regular times in the day and week to check your voicemail and email. Let others know that you will be using that schedule so they know when to expect a reply.
3. Focus on the person
When you switchtask when dealing with a computer, you simply lose efficiency. But if you switchtask on a human being, you additionally damage a relationship. Be present, listen carefully, and make sure everything has been taken care of before moving on.
For more information and a free subscription to Dave Crenshaw's newsletter, visit http://www.davecrenshaw.com
Multitasking is a myth. It just plain doesn't exist.
Does that shock you? Multitasking has become something of a heroic word in our vocabulary. Many executives pride themselves on their ability to "multitask". Recent job descriptions that I have seen even ask that potential employees have the ability to multitask. A current national commercial sings the praises of multitasking. However, multitasking, as most people understand it, is deceptively counter-productive. Multitasking is tremendously costly. Multitasking hurts us every time we attempt to engage in it.
I should clarify a few definitions. When I speak of multitasking as most people understand it, I am not referring to doing something completely mindless and mundane in the background such as exercising while listening to this CD, eating dinner and watching a show, or having the copy machine operate in the background while you answer emails. For clarity's sake, I call this "background tasking".
When most people refer to multitasking they mean simultaneously performing two or more things that require mental effort and attention. Examples would include saying we're spending time with family while were researching stocks online, attempting to listen to a CD and answering email at the same time, or pretending to listen to an employee while we are crunching the numbers. What most people refer to as multitasking, I refer to as "switchtasking." Why?
Because the truth is we really cannot do two things at the same time—we are only one person with only one brain. Neurologically speaking, it has been proven to be impossible. What we are really doing is switching back and forth between two tasks rapidly, typing here, paying attention there, checking our "crackberry" here, answering voicemail there back and forth back and forth at a high rate. Keep this up over a long period of time, and you have deeply engrained habits that cause stress and anxiety and dropped responsibilities and a myriad of productivity & focus problems. It's little wonder so many people complain of increasingly short attention spans!
When we speak of multitasking, what we really mean is that we are switchtasking: switching rapidly between one task and another. Yet, each time we switch, no matter how quickly that switch takes place in our mind, there is a cost associated with it. It's an economic term called switching cost—and the switching cost is high.
When I shared this principle of switchtasking to a CEO of a respected national company, she was astounded. We did a budgeting exercise where we looked at how much time she was spending in a given week. In the process of budgeting her time and looking at how much time she was spending on each activity, we found that she was extremely over budget in what she thought she could accomplish in a week. The truth is, there are only 168 hours in a week, and yet she had put down that she was accomplishing 188 hours worth of work in that week! As we went through the process, we realized where the extra time was coming from. It was from the fact that she was doing research at the same time that she was spending time with her family. When we came across this, I taught her how multitasking was a myth. She was spending time either with one or the other. She was switching rapidly between the two. In reality she was rarely spending any time with her family. She was really doing business research in the presence of her family. There is happy end to this story, however.
The next day we met she burst into the room, full of excitement. She exclaimed, "I'll have you know that I spent time with my family last night and I didn't multitask! I got home and said let's go to dinner. My kids were surprised. But we went to the restaurant and I paid attention to them and I didn't think about anything else but spending time with my family. At first I don't think they took me seriously. After they realized that I was really spending time with them and paying attention to them they were excited and I could tell they really appreciated it."
This CEO had come to understand that not only was switchtasking hurting her business, but it was taking a toll on her family. Once she clearly understood the truth and received some guidance on how to take action, she committed make changes. Her business, her family, and she are all better because of it.
May I offer the following "beginning steps" to help slow down the switchtasking in you life?
1. Take control over technology
Your cell phone ringer (even on vibrate) doesn't need to be on all the time. You can turn off email notification on your computer as well. Become master over the nagging beeps and buzzes by creating some silence.
2. Schedule what you can schedule
Set regular times in the day and week to check your voicemail and email. Let others know that you will be using that schedule so they know when to expect a reply.
3. Focus on the person
When you switchtask when dealing with a computer, you simply lose efficiency. But if you switchtask on a human being, you additionally damage a relationship. Be present, listen carefully, and make sure everything has been taken care of before moving on.
For more information and a free subscription to Dave Crenshaw's newsletter, visit http://www.davecrenshaw.com
Reply by Clouds
This post reminded me of some research done regarding multitasking.
Quote: "The shocking discovery of this research is that [high multitaskers] are lousy at everything that's necessary for multitasking."
For more see http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/8219212.stm
Quote: "The shocking discovery of this research is that [high multitaskers] are lousy at everything that's necessary for multitasking."
For more see http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/8219212.stm
Reply by Damien
I did the impossible: I read this, holding a pen, sitting on a chair and breathing lightly, all this while listening to the rain, ...
As for the Stanford study they have strange views about tasks. I guess they like to start the day counting the number of matches in three different matchboxes and continue categorising people walking left foot first while holding something in there right hand as opposed to...
- "They were briefly shown a screen with two red rectangles and either 0, 2, 4 or 6 blue rectangles."
- "a series of letters, one at a time, and told to push a button when they saw a letter that they had seen exactly three letters previously"
As for the Stanford study they have strange views about tasks. I guess they like to start the day counting the number of matches in three different matchboxes and continue categorising people walking left foot first while holding something in there right hand as opposed to...
- "They were briefly shown a screen with two red rectangles and either 0, 2, 4 or 6 blue rectangles."
- "a series of letters, one at a time, and told to push a button when they saw a letter that they had seen exactly three letters previously"
Reply by Mark Forster
Damien:
<< I did the impossible: I read this, holding a pen, sitting on a chair and breathing lightly, all this while listening to the rain, ... >>
And you missed the bit where David said:
"I am not referring to doing something completely mindless and mundane in the background such as exercising while listening to this CD, eating dinner and watching a show, or having the copy machine operate in the background while you answer emails...When most people refer to multitasking they mean simultaneously performing two or more things that require mental effort and attention. "
Perhaps if you'd paid less attention to the rain, you might have taken the article in better?
<< I did the impossible: I read this, holding a pen, sitting on a chair and breathing lightly, all this while listening to the rain, ... >>
And you missed the bit where David said:
"I am not referring to doing something completely mindless and mundane in the background such as exercising while listening to this CD, eating dinner and watching a show, or having the copy machine operate in the background while you answer emails...When most people refer to multitasking they mean simultaneously performing two or more things that require mental effort and attention. "
Perhaps if you'd paid less attention to the rain, you might have taken the article in better?
Reply by Mike
There are so many studies that approach this from different angles and they all come down to the same thing. Multi-tasking is basically just task switching and that requires overhead ... and often the overhead outweighs any gain. Plus, as most of these studies indicate, performance is degraded over and above just the cost of the overhead.
My ex-wife was a monster multi-tasker. She chided me for my "single thread" approach. (Can you tell we were both computer people? ;-) But watching her carefully, I saw how many mistakes she made, and how long she actually worked to get it all done. I realized that she did not recognize what I was getting done just because I was not a whirlwind of activity. Someone working with "head down" looks like a slug, but the end product is usually superior to the end product of the whirling dervish.
Also, if you consider today's environment, what bothers you most? For me it is the low quality of nearly everything and the general scatter brained level of performance by almost everyone.
Perhaps apropos of this I saw the film "Idiocracy" on TV a couple of nights ago. I just about lost it when they were all starving because the crops would not grow, after being watered with Gatorade. ROTFLMAO ;-)
"It has electrolytes. That's what plants need."
"What are electrolytes? Do you even know?"
"Yeah, what plants need."
My ex-wife was a monster multi-tasker. She chided me for my "single thread" approach. (Can you tell we were both computer people? ;-) But watching her carefully, I saw how many mistakes she made, and how long she actually worked to get it all done. I realized that she did not recognize what I was getting done just because I was not a whirlwind of activity. Someone working with "head down" looks like a slug, but the end product is usually superior to the end product of the whirling dervish.
Also, if you consider today's environment, what bothers you most? For me it is the low quality of nearly everything and the general scatter brained level of performance by almost everyone.
Perhaps apropos of this I saw the film "Idiocracy" on TV a couple of nights ago. I just about lost it when they were all starving because the crops would not grow, after being watered with Gatorade. ROTFLMAO ;-)
"It has electrolytes. That's what plants need."
"What are electrolytes? Do you even know?"
"Yeah, what plants need."
Reply by Mike
RE: Multi-tasking is not listening to a CD while exercising or eating while watching TV.
Not to put too fine a point on it, bu some of our overweight problems have to do with mindless eating ... so for that reason it is probably not good to eat while watching TV. Likewise, those who really study physical development advise against doing anything else while exercising. It takes full concentration to do really well.
As to the copier in the background, yeah, that's fine until it jams ;-)
I'm writing this with CPE Bach playing in the background. Maybe I should turn it off ;-)
Not to put too fine a point on it, bu some of our overweight problems have to do with mindless eating ... so for that reason it is probably not good to eat while watching TV. Likewise, those who really study physical development advise against doing anything else while exercising. It takes full concentration to do really well.
As to the copier in the background, yeah, that's fine until it jams ;-)
I'm writing this with CPE Bach playing in the background. Maybe I should turn it off ;-)
Reply by Mark Forster
Mike:
<< I'm writing this with CPE Bach playing in the background. >>
It depends what you are playing it for. If you are using it as "white noise" to cover up other possible auditory distractions, then fair enough. But is that really what CPE Bach's music is for?
<< I'm writing this with CPE Bach playing in the background. >>
It depends what you are playing it for. If you are using it as "white noise" to cover up other possible auditory distractions, then fair enough. But is that really what CPE Bach's music is for?
Reply by Damien
Mark
You're right, In fact I did not go farther than "Multitasking is a myth. It just plain doesn't exist." As I programmed a few multitasking systems (single controller, multi processor; not just task switching) I thought I was allowed to disagree. Of course the text would be long enough to contain disclaimers: When I say multitasking I mean ... task as a mental effort. OK. : Years ago, I played accordion: one hand for the rhythm, the other for the melody. I think this is an example of a multitasked mental effort, there is no reason those can not exist.
And yes I like listening to the rain.
Of topic: Thanks for the commented autofocus system section
You're right, In fact I did not go farther than "Multitasking is a myth. It just plain doesn't exist." As I programmed a few multitasking systems (single controller, multi processor; not just task switching) I thought I was allowed to disagree. Of course the text would be long enough to contain disclaimers: When I say multitasking I mean ... task as a mental effort. OK. : Years ago, I played accordion: one hand for the rhythm, the other for the melody. I think this is an example of a multitasked mental effort, there is no reason those can not exist.
And yes I like listening to the rain.
Of topic: Thanks for the commented autofocus system section
Reply by Mark Forster
Damien:
It is actually amazing what the brain can accomplish in the way of multi-tasking. I remember when I was in the Army we used to have radio headsets which were tuned into three different radio nets. One radio net would sound in one's left ear, one in one's right, and one in the middle of one's head. It was a bit like attending three cocktail parties at once. The amazing thing was that it was quite possible to keep track of all three nets and respond to them correctly, while also being involved in what was going on the immediate environment. I used to think "What I am doing is quite impossible - yet I'm doing it!"
However that and the example you give of the accordion and the system controller presuppose that the brain has been trained to deal with that combination, so that they have to all intents and purposes ceased to be multiple tasks and have become one task.
It is actually amazing what the brain can accomplish in the way of multi-tasking. I remember when I was in the Army we used to have radio headsets which were tuned into three different radio nets. One radio net would sound in one's left ear, one in one's right, and one in the middle of one's head. It was a bit like attending three cocktail parties at once. The amazing thing was that it was quite possible to keep track of all three nets and respond to them correctly, while also being involved in what was going on the immediate environment. I used to think "What I am doing is quite impossible - yet I'm doing it!"
However that and the example you give of the accordion and the system controller presuppose that the brain has been trained to deal with that combination, so that they have to all intents and purposes ceased to be multiple tasks and have become one task.